Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear is widely seen as one of the likeliest Democratic candidates to announce a 2028 presidential run early. History suggests that candidates lagging in early polls should announce early and drum up interest by being the first to openly declare and penetrate the news cycle.

And all the objective signs point to him moving forward to announcement quite soon.

Front-runners who don’t need name recognition (think AOC, Gavin Newsom, and Jon Ossoff) already have the name recognition and, in each of those cases, the ability to raise money very quickly and tap into a wide array of potential donors for 2028.

Now, Beshear certainly has the ability to organizationally launch a broad campaign.

He’s been the head of the Democratic Governors Association since 2025, spent the midterms helping Democratic gubernatorial nominees, and has already made plans to host prospective donors in Frankfort in December.

And he’s been on folks radar for a long time, having scored a statewide reelection in a red state while Joe Biden was president in 2023 — back when the Democratic party brand was tanking and Republicans were on their way to their sweeping 2024 win.

In fact, Beshear won, in part, thanks to a 43% approval rating among Republicans at the time.

And it’s not as if these were centrist Republicans in Vermont. This was Kentucky! He flipped 8 counties from blue to red in 2023, and I can’t stress enough that this was a time when having D next to your name might as well have meant Death Sentence.

All that to say — Beshear’s relatively comfortable win in a red state, in an unfavorable environment for his party — put his name on the national map, and he’s been seen as an inevitable candidate in the three years since.

Yet, in an Emerson poll of 2028 released just this week, he sat at just 4% among Democrats on national preference, far behind candidates who can afford to wait much longer to make presidential decisions and will immediately dominate the national conversation once they do.

In short, the longer Beshear waits to announce, the more likely he is to be drowned out by the front-runners who start rolling out their campaigns.

As a laggard in preference, he’s got to be a front-runner in announcement to build buzz.

So he’s got to do it early.

Now, how should he do it?

The traditional way might be to blitz the media with press releases, give a speech in his homestate, highlight his accomplishments, and outline his vision for the country.

And that would generate some headlines, to be sure.

The edgier way would be to go on a left-leaning podcast and show that he’s ready to lean into new media. He’d be making a case to sympathetic listeners and voters who will actually, you know, vote in a Democratic primary.

But there’s a third way, and it’s probably the most daring, edgiest, and most certain to score him a place in the broader political zeitgeist — book a podcast with a conservative-leaning host and just announce there. No press release, no leak, just chat and make news.

Here are a couple, glaring advantages.

First, even though the conservative manosphere podcasts have grown disillusioned with politics, there’s got to be some kind of host in that realm (maybe you don’t get Joe Rogan, but Theo Von would be a huge get, and even Julian Dorey, with this 1.47 million subscribers or maybe Patrick David Bet, as another example) who’d be interested in having some kind of post-mortem on the 2026 results with a red state Democrat who they suspect will run for president.

In short, I don’t think Beshear would have particular trouble getting booked, and especially, if he were to give a heads-up to the host he’d be announcing on their show.

That’s instant subscribers and a huge publicity boost for any podcast. Especially a conservative one — to have the first Democratic presidential candidate announce on your show.

Sure, Beshear might face some tougher questions.

But here’s the fact — James Talarico shot to national prominence when he chose to go on a podcast where he knew he’d face uncomfortable questions (Joe Rogan’s) and showed he could handle the scrutiny, unfazed, and in a winning, compelling manner.

In fact, Talarico’s surprising appearance on conservative-leaning Rogan’s podcast is exactly what catapulted him to fame.

Soon after his July 2025 appearance in which Rogan urged him to run for president, The Hill commented on it by calling Talarico’s potential run “a darkhorse bid”, and it garnered attention by pretty much every major outlet, including Politico which ran a piece in its magazine, “Joe Rogan’s Latest Guest Might Turn Texas Blue.”

This was before Talarico had even announced a Senate run and wasn’t taken particularly seriously! That’s how powerful the appearance on a conservative podcast was.

After his hit, suddenly everyone in the political sphere, including Democratic donors both small and large, were talking about Talarico.

Would that have been possible if Talarico had gone on left-leaning Pod Save America? No way.

The fact is – if you can hang for 2+ hrs with a host who has different political beliefs from yours, an audience that isn’t naturally receptive to your ideology, and make your case eloquently, you get unbelievable free media and are suddenly on the lips of everyone.

Democrats watched Talarico and thought, “Wow! We’ve found a way to crack the code!” They wouldn’t have said that if he’d gone on a left-leaning podcast.

And if Beshear’s pitch is what it already is — I’m the guy who can build a broad, winning coalition — then go make a splash by announcing on a conservative-leaning podcast and impress the host.

That’ll instantly make you more viable to Democratic voters, gives you max media attention, and underscores your pitch about electability.

Those are the components you need if you’re a darkhorse, and ultimately, that’s the opening formula for pulling off what Talarico did in winning Texas.

Part of the knock on Beshear is that he’s a buttoned-up guy who doesn’t feel exciting. A traditional announcement would just underscore that.

The smartest way to change the narrative on your personality and candidacy is to turn your presidential announcement into something exciting that buttresses your main, overall pitch that you’re the guy who can impress the other half of the country.

That’s the way to move up from 4% and lagging badly in the race.

If you’re behind, if you don’t have a buzz, to have a shot, you’ve got to take a shot.

[Photo: Public Domain, attribution: Dale Greer]

0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

In the wake of 2028’s stunning upsets in Texas, Florida Gov Ron DeSantis took to X to call on Elon Musk to move his numerous companies based in Texas to Florida. DeSantis responded to an X user suggestion with a simple: “LFG!”

There are a couple things to note here.

First, Elon Musk isn’t the most popular guy in America last night (just a 37% favorable rating, according to Decision Desk), and his massive spend of $446 million on the midterms showed the limits of his political power. Yes, he has X. Yes, he has influencers. But the ones who decided the election last night? The working class? Hispanics? That’s not Elon Musk’s base. Additionally, Musk is associated with data centers and AI, which is deeply unpopular, according to a recent U Mass poll.

So DeSantis sending a welcoming text to Elon wouldn’t seem the best immediate thing to do.

But…

For whatever his shortcomings in a general election, every Republican candidate would want to get the nod of Elon Musk in a 2028 presidential primary. He has a massive platform, scores of admirers, influence with the base, and again, lots and lots of money.

He will have a say in the race – with his tweets and his money. A big say.

There’s this too.

DeSantis is one of the only winners for the Republican party last night. On Stephen Smith’s show, he had considerable criticism for ways in which the Trump Administration had lost its way with voters, including calling the Iran War a “big, big drag” on the GOP. That was BEFORE the election results. So he showed some prescience there.

Additionally, DeSantis wasn’t on the ballot, so he didn’t have to face the landscape, his Republican replacement (Byron Donalds) barely squeaked by in Florida’s governor race, DeSantis isn’t in the Trump Administration, and was the most credible challenger to Trump in 2028 for the base.

Also there’s this. After last night, DeSantis saw a massive jump in his Kalshi odds to become the GOP nominee – skyrocketing 14 pts, while JD Vance shed 8, and Rubio 1. This puts DeSantis suddenly at 19 cents – unbelievably close to Vance’s 27%. More on this later, but DeSantis is the guy who’s the immediate. obvious winner from last night.

0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

In the wake of Politico’s report that Justice Samuel Alito is considering retirement, Michigan Senator and possible 2028 presidential candidate Elissa Slotkin, called for both term limits and age limits for Supreme Court justices.

Her message on X was brief was and definitive:

It’s an interesting move, politically, because it puts her to the right of the far left (which has called for more Supreme Court justices), but her call is also more progressive than we’ve seen from previous centrist Democrats, which seems to be the lane Slotkin is running in (okay, probably is running in).

To wit: when talking of the possibility of running for president, she laid forth clearly in the center (and purchased the plane tickets to spread her message to, oh, states like Iowa).

Michigan Public Radio from June 8:

Slotkin said a political figure from a midwestern swing state might appeal to a broad swath of voters across the country who are more interested in problem-solving than ideology.

“I think we’re a practical, reasonable people who know how to work hard,” she said. “No one would ever call us flashy. We just put our heads down and get things done, and that is what we need more of, certainly in my party, but I think in both.”

And even though she didn’t endorse him in the primary, she is supporting and now campaigning for Al-Sayed in Michigan’s general election, while maintaining that she supports the Jewish state, telling a Politco Summit that: “I believe in a Jewish state of Israel, yes. And to me that isn’t a radical thing to say….I can say that in the same breath that I criticize the military policy of Bibi Netanyahu.”

That’s actually become a pretty centrist view for a general election.

The latest Gallup polling shows 57% support for a 2-state solution with 28% opposing it. Young groups and progressives might be increasingly moving against Israel, but again, the most reliable voters (older age groups) are more likely to side with Israel.

Sloktin has generally focused on the kind of issues less likely to rev up the progressive base, but more likely to motivate centrist Democrats and independents.

She often talks of the Four Corners of the Kitchen Table when making her pitch: housing, healthcare, food, and electricity bills. Here she is earlier this year.

And at the Iowa Polk County Democratic Dinner, Slotkin further distanced herself from the coastal elites, per Henry Gomez’s reporting.

“Us Midwestern Democrats need to stick together. It’s a tough thing to be a Midwestern Democrat, right?”

“Sometimes,” Slotkin added, “the national party forgets about the middle of the country or forgets about us until the federal elections or national elections.”

Finally, here’s the surprising thing.

Despite her interest and despite the fact that Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer is showing fewer signs of being interested in a run, Slotkin only registers at .5% on Kalshi.

That makes her a darkhorse and one who’s pretty good at creating viral moments (her interview on Maher’s show, for example) and presenting what I’d call a “dogmatic centrist Democratic” pitch.

Why, exactly, is Rahm Emanuel (charting a similar course) a stronger favorite on Kalshi right now?

Who can really go farther in a nominating contest? Centrist and fresh-faced Slotkin seems to have more upside as a darkhorse than Centrist Emanuel, who’s firmly of the old guard of Democrats.

Keep an eye on her.

0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

I’d encourage you to read this piece by David Graham of The Atlantic.

He goes into detail on Obama’s somewhat tortured (that word seems to contradict his calm mien, but the tension in action is obvious) relationship between the party’s increasingly leftist progressive movement and his own centrist-left beliefs.

Read Graham and draw your own conclusions, but my hunch is this:

If you’re looking for Obama to endorse a presidential primary candidate in 2028, wait until it’s clear who the winning candidate is going to be.

I can’t see him publicly sticking his neck out for nobody, for a few reasons.

First, I don’t think he wants to short-circuit the candidate drawing the most enthusiasm unless the front-runner after the first few primaries is a clear Crisis Candidate who’ll Bomb a General Election. That’s Obama, the Sincere Pragmatic Democrat Who Wants to Save His Party and Win.

Second, my hunch is that he’s got quite a bit of pride in his bones and doesn’t want the political shame of an early endorsement of someone who turns out to lose the primary.

That’s Obama, the Proud Professor who just happened to become President and is the most popular politician in America. Don’t underestimate the pride and statistical validation that comes with that.

Third, he seems to be in that gray area between senior statesman who’s stepped aside versus reluctant but restless patron of a party he wants to win.

It seems there’s a lot of dissonance — not in his words, but actions. As Graham puts it, “He is in an awkward phase of his career — no longer young enough to be cool but still too young to be an elder statesman.”

In short, he’s not going to try to hold onto the past like Norma Desmond, but his concern for both his country and his reputation and legacy probably bump up against each other.

Just because he was president doesn’t mean he isn’t immune to the dynamic of the High School Football Star who’s now in his 40s and can’t entirely make peace with the dimming of the Friday Night Lights.

And just because he’s not immune to that doesn’t mean he doesn’t care about his country or his party in the best possible way.

All of this to say — it’ll be fun to speculate about Obama’s preferred 2028 candidate, but it’s unlikely he’ll be in a rush to his old line “let’s be clear” about it until the primary has proven what’s clear about it.

[Photo: Obama and Mauricio Macri, by Casa Rosada, CC BY 2.5 ar]

0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

In December 2025, potential 2028 Republican presidential candidate and Gov. Spencer Cox delivered one of the most gut-punch lines to tech executives at an AI Summit at the Utah Department of Commerce.

“However much you hate social media, you do not hate it enough. You do not hate these companies enough.”

I’m flagging that comment for a few reasons.

A) Since he’s relatively unknown, that quote just hasn’t circulated, and it’s a good one.

In an age of pejorative platitudes over social media, that quote stands out for its unvarnished passion and lack of disclaimer.

I can easily see it becoming a thing if he chooses to run and use it.

Oh, and there’s more from the same speech, as Utah’s KSL reported:

“They gave your daughter an eating disorder, and they gave your son a pornography addiction, and they gave our grandkids anxiety and depression, and many of them took their own lives. And they did it knowingly. They had studied the results. We’re finding this out now through lawsuits that they knew what they were doing, and they did it anyway.”

He added that the powerful tech companies have tried to “strip mine our souls.”

B) MAHA (Make America Healthy Again) would love the line, and I’m sure Jonathan Haidt and many parents would approve.

So would many other country’s school systems, which are increasingly banning smartphones specifically because of the access they offer to social media.

UNESCO reports that more than half of countries now have some form of smart phone bans in schools, which is a remarkable global epidemic (the good kind).

If you’re wondering just how toxic social media companies’ content has become, you can point to the fact that 32% of teenage girls felt worse about their bodies after using Instagram.

And if you’re wondering how the companies are about the harm, that statistic comes from Facebook’s own research.

I could cite stat after stat about the effects on every part of young people’s lives or you could just read Haidt’s book, which you’ve probably already consumed in some form.

The long and short of it is — parents are fed up, social media companies are tipping perilously close to being viewed as vice companies (ala cigarette makers), and there’s an entire voter demographic to be harnessed that is one of the drivers in RFK’s popularity.

And speaking of which, you’ve gotta bookmark this new Politico poll that’s a great deep-dive on what MAHA believes and includes this fascinating tidbit — men were more likely to identify as MAHA supporters than women.

C) Now AI is obviously different from social media, but it’s in the same basket of public concern.

And Cox has taken here a pretty nuanced view.

On the one hand, he’s been an advocate of helping the AI industry in Utah, and as the Utah Dispatch notes, he believes in its potential to solve important problems, including launching a “pro-AI initiative” and putting state cash behind it.

But on the other hand, he’s strenuously urged government to put guardrails on two things.

The first is AI’s potential to exploit children, and thus he’s a firm believer in state regulation and control, unwilling to entrust the federal government with such a delicate and important task.

The social media quote connection is that — if you can see what social media has done to kids, can you imagine AI’s impact?

The second is his philosophical belief that AI companies shouldn’t be dominated by a few giants and that users should have more control over their own data.

Alixel Cabrera of the Utah Dispatch.

….a big [state legislative] focus will be preventing anti-competitive actions by big tech companies, an issue Utah lawmakers started to work on this year, when they approved the first law in the nation to push tech companies towards interoperability, allowing users to own their own data

“We need to make sure that we don’t end up with five AI companies. We need thousands of AI companies in this country,” Cox said. 

So, I just wanted to give a little context for what I think is a killer political line for a 2028 candidate to make a name for himself.

As for the rest of who Spencer Cox is and why he’s an interesting voice and might show up on a debate stage (you can imagine his calling out JD Vance’s ties to Peter Theil and the AI industry as a viral moment that could trip JD up), I’ll write more in the future.

0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

In a new interview with the Harvard Political Review, 2028 potential Democratic candidate Pete Buttigieg delivers one of the most effective, aspirational stump lines I’ve heard in awhile on “freedom,” which is currently one of the most disputed concepts in our democracy.

(Hey, free to dispute freedom, right?)

HPR: What does Pete Buttigieg stand for?

PB: One way that I try to shorthand it is freedom, security, and democracy, properly understood. That means freedom not just from, but freedom to. I think that in order to be free, you need a government that can provide basic services, and that can protect you from anyone who would make you unfree, including itself.
 I think security includes economic as well as physical security. And I think that a good democracy can deliver all of that. 

What I care about is making sure that we get our government to do the things that it needs to do for us to live a better everyday life. The government can’t make you thrive, but it can tear down the barriers between you and living the life of your choosing. I got into public service because I think it matters who’s making those decisions and what their priorities are. 


Now note that: “Freedom not just from, but freedom to.”

Sharp.

Now even though that’s a great line, it’s not immediately accessible.

It’s a little wonky, but it frames the rest of what he says in an extremely effective way.

In the era of Donald Trump, Democrats have been seized by “freedom from” — in other words, the overall goal to be free from the Trump era. If you’re a Democrat, it’s easy to see why. And it will probably get a lot of Democrats elected this fall.

But ever since Trump arrived on the scene, there’s the temptation for Democratic message-drift.

The entire platform becomes “freedom from” and therefore dominated by Donald Trump.

Voters know all about Trump and MAGA. They don’t need to be reminded. Trump won’t stop voters from being reminded. Centrist voters might want freedom from, but they want to know — what’s the Democratic party providing that’s freedom to?

The key for Democrats is offering an aspirational alternative, and that all stems from “freedom to” and not “freedom from.”

Pete spells out what freedom to looks like — “tear down the barriers between you and the living the life of your choosing.”

Now that’s a great campaign message, all stemming from the intellectual building block of “freedom to.”

Now… I’m not sure Americans are ready for 30 second commercials that are simply tag-lined “freedom to.”

But I’d bet they’re hungry for a commercial where every sentence begins with “freedom to… X, Y, and Z,” where, of course, X, Y, and Z are substantive issues that resonate with the vast and influential center of Americans.

How does that play out in a Democratic nomination? I’m not sure. It’s hard to know the climate in 2028. Right now, aspirational messages don’t really get you the clicks.

But Democrats should realize that if they want to win, they’re going to have to go on Rogan, Shaun Ryan, Theo Von, Flagrant etc., and if you can offer something that’s not just freedom from but freedom to, then that’s got the potential to be a winning message.

I’ll get to more about the interview in a separate post, but I had to flag that statement as Classic Pete in how he thinks (theoretically) and then can offer a coherent message based upon a central premise.

It’s a unique skill, but the top tier all have their unique gifts. Hence, the top tier.

0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

Fresh off her viral turn on Bill Maher’s show, The Des Moines Register reports that Michigan Sen. Elissa Slotkin is headed to… Iowa.

U.S. Sen. Elissa Slotkin, D-Mich., will hold a town hall in Des Moines focused on health care with Democratic congressional hopeful Sarah Trone Garriott during a coming visit to Iowa.

Slotkin’s visit to meet with swing voters in Iowa and campaign for Democratic congressional hopefuls comes as she boosts her national presence ahead of the 2026 midterm elections.

Slotkin posted this clip on X yesterday, and notice what’s in there (it’s the economy, stupid) and what’s not in there. (Iran, Israel, culture wars).

She often refers to this as her Four Corners Pitch.

Slotkin is only at .3% on Kalshi, well behind her state’s governor Gretchen Whitmer, whom Axios has noted multiple times over the past year seems to be losing her fire for running for president.

Keep an eye on Slotkin if you’re thinking Michigan entry into the race. Oh, and Pete, I guess.

Here’s one of many notable moments on Maher — after which he remarked she could run for president.

Hat tip: Austin Cook X acct.

0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

Considering top tier 2028 candidates, Georgia Sen. Jon Ossoff rarely pops up in national news headlines and, in my book, at this stage, that’s a good sign.

He’s focused on a reelection race and if he loses, his 2028 stock takes a massive hit.

The best thing he can do for 2028 is keep out of national affairs, focus on getting reelected in Georgia, and then pivot to national ambitions.

To keep up with Ossoff, here’s what’s been going on.

A) Liz Goodwin’s must-read Washington Post piece, “Republicans privately fear this swing state Democrat.“

Since Ossoff (barely) won his special election seat in 2021, Republicans have looked hopefully on knocking off Ossoff, claiming he’s too liberal for Georgia.

But, according to Goodwin, “behind closed doors, Republicans have tamped down their hopes.”

“I’m not feeling bullish about it,” said one Republican strategist who was granted anonymity to provide a more candid assessment. “[Ossoff] has wisely avoided the temptation of going on cable news for six years and playing to the base for social media likes. … I think he’s going to reap the benefits of that.”

In fact, one potential opponent, Buddy Carter, recently told folks:

“Look, this guy’s no slouch…. He’s pretty sharp, he’s articulate, he’s young, he’s handsome, he talks well. You better have somebody who can go toe to toe with him.”

(Of course, all that may be true, but the caveat is that Carter is in a competitive, super messy primary with MAGA-favorite Buddy Collins, who leads substantially in most GOP primary polls, and it’s in Carter’s best interest to portray Ossoff as a guy who can only be knocked off by a a more palatable general election nominee).

And Goodwin says Ossoff has started to pivot (I think a touch too soon, personally) to national issues.

…..he’s broken from his hyper-local focus in recent months to deliver stinging attacks on Trump and his administration that have won him admiration from national Democrats. A speech he gave in suburban Atlanta excoriating Trump for empowering a wealthy “Epstein class” to rule the country while slashing public services went viral. And in recent remarks at a Black church, Ossoff lashed out at the Trump administration’s actions as evil, criticizing Republicans from a biblical perspective.

Read the whole piece here, but you’ll find the general picture of a guy you shouldn’t underestimate for 2028.

(And btw, if you’re curious, here’s the full speech in Atlanta to which Goodwin referred.)

Also note – according to RCP’s average of Georgia polling, Ossoff maintains narrow (3-5%) leads on his potential Georgia Democratic opponents in 2026.

His national hopes depend pretty heavily, I think, on whether he wins.

B) His most buzzy moment, as of late – the grilling of Tulsi Gabbard in the Senate Intelligence Committee Hearing on Worldwide Threats, March 18, on whether Iran did, indeed, pose an imminent nuclear threat, considering she had previously said its program was “obliterated,” with “no efforts since then to rebuild their enrichment capability.”

After that, he pivoted to the controversial Fulton County raid.

Two things: a) He’s really sharp here — precise and strong without grandstanding (or nastiness) and b) it fits in line with his normal duties, so it’s not as if he’s going outside his Georgia Senator box in this viral moment.

The clip went viral with a range of analysts praising Ossoff’s line of questioning, from political influencers like Jon Favreau and Joannne Carducci to officials like retired US Navy Intel officer, Travis Akers, and NYU law professor Ryan Goodman.

C) The “Alligator Alcatraz Investigation.”

This is a substantive investigation with legs that both a) fits in line with Ossoff’s committee duties and b) gets him involved in an issue that has national implications — the treatment of ICE detainees.

Whereas the Gabbard clip stood out for its viral component, Ossoff and Dick Durban have launched an official investigation into allegations of “Alligator Alcatraz” torture.

The investigation is a response to concerns raised by Amnesty International, as well as Florida-based WLRN news reports.

Key passage from Ossoff and Durban’s letter:

“There have been credible allegations that detainees at ‘Alligator Alcatraz’ have been punished with confinement in a small cage-like structure known as ‘the box,’ where they are held in stress positions with hands and feet tightly shackled for hours at a time, in direct sunlight with no access to food or water.”

One political note — the investigation could help insulate him a bit from splitting with Dems on the Laken Riley Act that expanded detention for immigrants accused of certain crimes.

D) In an interview with Politico’s Adam Wren, Hasan Piker calls Ossoff his “darkhorse pick” for 2028.

Wow.

Piker is really controversial and really influential, and one advisor to a potential 2028 candidate told Politico they expect Piker has legs as a “gatekeeper” for the 2028 primary. Not sure that’s great for the party’s general election nominee, but what do I know.

My question – is Piker just playing political prognosticator w/Ossof here or saying: You know, I like this Ossoff guy a lot.

It seems… seems… that it’s the latter, based on the context of the quote.

“I said [Georgia Sen. Jon] Ossoff will be my dark horse pick, depending on how he presents himself if he has ambitions for higher office. I do love [UAW President] Shawn Fain personally. I like an outsider pick. I like Ro Khanna. I like AOC. I actually like [Sen.] Chris Van Hollen, quite a bit as well, even.”

Jewish Insider notes that Ossoff hasn’t responded to Piker’s comment, claiming that the silence speaks loudly.

Ossoff is Jewish. That puts any Democrat in an awkward position for 2028. Piker will be watching him closely on issues related to Israel, and that’ll be an interesting dynamic to keep in mind.

Kalshi Odds for Democratic Nominee, April 2, 2026: 6.6%, good for 3rd place behind Newsom and Cortez.

Considering that strong showing, weird he’s still considered a darkhorse.

0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez teamed up with Bernie Sanders last week to introduce a bill that would put a moratorium on building new AI data centers (read here, and notice it leads with examples of numerous AI and business titans talking about its effect on industry) until certain conditions are met – namely, creating federal safeguards for AI to curb it from “affecting everything from our economy and well-being, to our democracy, warfare and our kids’ education.”

Here’s vid from AOC’s portion of the press conference.

Some key voices in the Democratic party immediately voiced opposition, which indicates the bill is probably doomed but not the political messaging.

More on that later.

First, to AOC’s presser:

Notice a few things.

  1. She talks about layoffs associated with AI – both ones that have already been attributed to it and those that have been warned about.
  2. Then she immediately shifts to Sam Altman’s testimony before Congress where he “begged us to regulate this industry” to prevent mass layoffs and benefit working people.”
  3. She followed with another Altman quote from 10 years ago: “AI will probably lead to the end of the world, but in the meantime there will be great companies created.” (some context to that quote here).
  4. AOC: “It’s our responsibility to take care of the people”; not Altman’s company (OpenAI) or said-companies.”

Now here’s the money quote that shows where the messaging is going on this:

AOC:

“Unfortunately, the leaders of this industry have repeated time and time again that they view working people as an endless untapped market to be manipulated and exploited.

That they would sell our country out if it meant that they could turn a profit.”

Translation: Wealth inequality.

Another potent message beyond wealth inequality — Privacy.

AOC:

“It is no surprise that in the four years since ChatGPT was released, we have seen AI deployed at a massive scale to create Big Brother-type surveillance.”

She continues:

“Companies like Palantir are mining endlessly the data and privacy of the American people, keeping track of everything that they say and do and sending it all to a militarized and centralized government.”

And why Americans should take the privacy threat seriously:

“When you take the subway, when you share a Tik-Tok, when you talk to your Alexa at home, they are collecting your data and figuring out new ways to weaponize it. And now they are using AI tools to automatize this so that it is not only pervasive but that it is effortless. We must sound the alarm now.”

Now to another political message — Affordability.

“These companies are now so desperate to profit off of the AI boom that they are racing to construct thousands of giant AI data centers and jacking up the utility costs of everyday Americans to pay for it. These data centers power thousands of high intensity computer chips that are processing at all times and require massive amounts of energy.”

And so… “People’s energy bills around the country are skyrocketing in order to pay for these AI data centers for them.”

Plainly: She integrates wealth inequality, privacy, and affordability into one issue (AI data centers), and that’s pretty good politics.

Here’s what gives it extra kick — some of AI’s biggest backers are practically household names.

The two most visible names are Sam Altman and Elon Musk, both of whom are very rich, very visible, and very controversial.

Another obvious name is Peter Thiel, though he isn’t quite a household name, although it’s getting there. And of course Alex Karp, who has all the makings of getting there, as well.

In normal class politics, progressive politicians usually say the “billionaires running the system.” But “Larry Fink” is gonna draw a lot of blank stares.

In other words, AOC already has data center foils that are controversy magnets (and magnates).

That matters, politically.

Her closing message: If AI wins, Altman, Musk and the Bro-Logarchs get richer, and you have to foot the bill of these huge data centers.

That last point is increasingly being addressed, but AI leaders let Americans paying high utility bills go on long enough that I think it’s contributed to a crystalizing of negative public thought towards it.

However…

Politically: Like I said, this billl is unlikely to pass.

At Axios’ AI+ DC Summit, key Democratic Sen. Mark Warner immediately called the idea of a moratorium “idiocy…. a data center moratorium simply means China is going to move quicker” and “the idea that we’re going to stuff this back into the bottle, this genie, that’s a ridiculous premise.”

John Fetterman also squashed the idea on X: “I refuse to help hand the lead in AI to China. The AI chassis can either come from China or the USA. That’s an easy choice.”

But ironically, that might actually help AOC’s fight.

In politics, fighting a losing battle can be a win, if a) the public is on your side of the message and b) it fits into a broader argument that’s also politically popular at this moment – that the middle and lower classes are getting increasingly squeezed by cost of living while the richer are getting richer.

And AOC has reason to think taking on AI in some fashion could be a popular cause.

In fact, an NBC poll this month showed registered voters think the the risks of AI outweigh the benefits, 57%-34%.

And here’s something fascinating about the poll – the youngest are most negative!

The demographic groups with the most negative views of AI are voters ages 18-34, among whom the net favorability rating for AI is minus 44, and women ages 18-49, who reported a net AI favorability rating of minus 41.

In other words, the group most opposed to new technology is the younger generation.

My guess – because young college graduates are struggling to find new jobs and younger adults are constantly hearing warnings (including from AI leaders) about vast swaths of jobs that could be wiped out in the future.

Having a foil that you essentially can’t stop (the inexorable advance of AI) can actually work in your favor because you don’t have to come up with something that addresses the need to adapt to the globe’s changing reality (Warner’s concerns).

Thus, I don’t think AOC and Bernie can win, legislatively, on this, but politically? Yeah. I think so.

It’s one of those issues that highlights the macro frustration of wealth inequality + the growing mass movement against what technology is really doing to us (the success of Jonathan Haidt’s Anxious Generation has become so vast that you can see a political movement arising from it).

AOC has a winning issue here, politically, even if it’s bound to fail.

And I don’t think she’s doing it cynically.

This fits perfectly with the consistent message she and Bernie have been highlighting on their Fighting the Oligarchy Tour. And it’s been a winning one across the country, as the affordability issue that doomed Democrats in 2024 threatens to doom Republicans in 2026.

On X, yesterday, she tweeted this warning:

Now, I do think the Trump Administration gets the political threat that AI poses to GOP.

The AP’s Matthew Daly:

The White House said last week that Congress should “preempt state AI laws” that it views as too burdensome, laying out a broad framework for how it wants Congress to address concerns about AI without curbing growth or innovation in the sector.

The legislative blueprint outlines a half-dozen guiding principles for lawmakers, focusing on protecting children, preventing electricity costs from surging, respecting intellectual property rights, preventing censorship and educating Americans on using the technology.

Companies that committed to Trump’s pledge to protect ratepayers include Google, Microsoft, Meta, Oracle, xAI, OpenAI and Amazon. The companies agreed to build or buy new sources of power generation for their data centers and cover the expense of infrastructure upgrades.

In other words, the Administration is “Full Steam Ahead!” while also recognizing the severe political vulnerability of its push on AI.

Browse the All-In Podcast, and you’ll see vid after vid of some of the most influential pro-AI voices acknowledging the industry faces a deep crisis in messaging.

So I doubt AOC wins on vote count here, but politics, yeah.

Axios’ Maria Curi notes:

AI’s massive energy demands are scrambling party lines, and efforts to halt construction could be an attractive political message on both sides of the aisle ahead of the midterms.

Now…. here’s another political thing to keep an eye on:

Some things in life are powered by Duracell.

JD Vance’s political ascent has been significantly powered by AI titans like Peter Thiel (See this classic piece from The New York Times: “How a network of tech billionaires helped JD Vance Leap into Power.”

AOC and JD seem to reserve special animosity towards one another (examples: here and here, but there are tons out there) that goes beyond the “Hey, I might run against you in 2028” jockeying.

One final thought: I’ve got a hunch that Palantir is on its way to becoming the bete noire of AI with Alex Karp and Peter Thiel the horsemen.

By the time it’s 2028, there’s a reasonable chance that Dems are throwing around nicknames of billionaires like “Peter Palantir Thiel” and somehow linking them to JD Vance in a way that makes things stick.

After all, the famous irony is that JD made his political career from the backstory of the hollowing out of manufacturing, yet might himself be an integral player in a future that could hollow out multiple industries.

Whether it’s AOC or someone else making that connection remains to be seen, but expect to hear a lot more from AOC on AI (unless, of course, everyone loves it by then).

0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

David Axelrod, with this quote to Politico in Adam Wren’s fantastic read on Pete Buttigieg’s multi-state, multi-coalition, multi-outreach, maximalist approach to building a winning coalition.

“He had a remarkable run in 2020 and ultimately, one of the, perhaps the greatest obstacle, is that he didn’t have much of a relationship with African American voters.”

“And the fact that he’s spending a lot of time communing with Black voters across the country even if in the service of the midterm elections, is a reflection that he’s not headed for early retirement.”

You really need to read the piece because the whole Pete strategy (both philosophically and operationally) is pretty much there, but there’s this continual question that no one likes to talk about, but is one of the most daunting for Pete’s chances: Considering he’s gay, can Pete win enough black voters to win the nomination?

It’s the most ubiquitous, quiet question there is, because it assumes a homophobia among blacks, and progressives fear that accusation against such a valuable part of the Democratic coalition.

But Dems’ bleed in 2024 among Hispanics and Blacks was partially thanks to a leadership and activist base that had gone too far to the Left of Hispanics and Blacks on cultural issues.

Polling shows blacks are more religious than whites, more likely than others to read the Bible regularly, viewing it as God’s word, and thus more likely to be associated with denominations that consider homosexuality a sin.

That’s just the way it is.

It’s a demographic reality, and the Democratic party doesn’t want to say it out-loud, but Pete certainly know the dynamics.

After all, he earned less than 2% of the black vote when he ran for president in South Carolina. That, after finishing 2nd, overall, in Iowa and New Hampshire — which had far fewer blacks voting.

So while Pete’s shown tier 1 operational, rhetorical, and strategic capacity, it’s going to be a “prove-it” issue in much the same way Barack Obama’s was.

And in case you were wondering, Politico noted that a February Emerson poll had Pete running at 6% of the black vote, while Newsom scored 17% and Harris 36%.

That’s not as bad as it looks for Pete. Harris, of course, has sky high name ID, Newsom is up there too, and so Pete scoring 6% isn’t terrible. But of course not great.

And to that end, Wren notes:

Buttigieg has increased his engagement with Black candidates like Greene and the community more broadly, addressing a perceived weakness. In Alabama, Buttigieg joined civil rights leaders and community members in Selma for the Bridge Crossing Jubilee and Anniversary of Bloody Sunday, and made remarks at a unity breakfast and Tabernacle Baptist Church. In Birmingham, he joined a roundtable with business owners from the Historic 4th Avenue Business District.

Now, you couldn’t do better than to read the rest of Wren’s piece because it really shows how strategic Pete is about building a coalition and a winning strategy. It’s all about addition — demographics, venues, messaging, diversity of thought.

He’s not out there looking for the big 12 hr news cycle soundbite like a lot of the other Democratic contenders.

He’s squarely thinking about building a coalition that can win a general election.

And that will have to include a lot of traditionally religious black and Hispanic voters.

0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
-
00:00
00:00
Update Required Flash plugin
-
00:00
00:00